How this trust score was computed
Trust blends alignment (40%): does the outlet rank games the way players do; decoded accuracy (30%): after translating the outlet's own scale habits (a '7/10 means mediocre' scale is decoded, not punished), how well its reviews predict player sentiment; and player-side (30%): on games where press consensus and players sharply disagreed, whose side it took. Recent reviews weigh more (2-year half-life), and the blend is shrunk toward a neutral prior (60) so small samples can't peg the scale. Player quality is launch-window Steam sentiment, so outlets aren't punished for reviewing a launch build that later got patched.
Controversy record: on 18 games where press consensus and players sharply disagreed, this reviewer sided with players 1 time.
Computed 6m ago · full methodology →
Outlet vs. players
Each dot is a game both this outlet and players scored. The dashed line is perfect agreement: dots above it mean the outlet was more generous than players, below it more harsh.
Biggest disagreements with players
The receipts: games where this outlet's verdict landed furthest from player sentiment.
- +35Pokemon Swordoutlet 89 · players 54 · Nov 2019
- +34Pokemon Shieldoutlet 89 · players 55 · Nov 2019
- +42EA Sports FC 24outlet 80 · players 38 · Sep 2023
- -20Astral Chainoutlet 65 · players 86 · Aug 2019
- +20Animal Crossing: New Horizonsoutlet 90 · players 70 · Mar 2020
- +22Cyberpunk 2077outlet 94 · players 72 · Dec 2020
- +41Battlefield™ 2042outlet 80 · players 39 · Nov 2021
- +37Total War: WARHAMMER IIIoutlet 85 · players 48 · Feb 2022
- +13Demon's Soulsoutlet 92 · players 79 · Nov 2020
- +24Halo Infiniteoutlet 92 · players 69 · Dec 2021
Recent reviews (256 tracked)
- 70Star FoxJun 24, 2026
“Star Fox 2026 is a high-quality remake of a game that hasn’t aged all that well. Lylat Wars still has its moments, which are elevated here thanks to Velan Studios’ production and a top-notch soundtrack. But beneath the brand-new skin, it’s still the heart of a late-’90s rail shooter that beats. So rather than for newer generations, we’d recommend this lovely “Madeleine de Proust” primarily to those feeling nostalgic.”
read full review ↗ - 65Gothic 1 RemakeJun 11, 2026
“Even though it’s far from perfect, Gothic 1 Remake succeeds in significantly modernizing the original game while preserving everything that made it so charming. It’s still an old-school RPG, offering players a great deal of freedom and the chance to lose themselves in a world that’s both extremely harsh and distinctive, without ever holding their hand. But now, it’s much richer visually, and some of the gameplay flaws have been smoothed out a bit. This doesn’t erase all the clunkiness and flaws of the original game, while the improvements to combat and the interface clearly didn’t go far enough. The numerous bugs and performance issues are also real problems at this point. Even for Gothic fans and those seeking an old-school experience, it’s best to wait before diving in, for an optimal gaming experience.”
read full review ↗ - 85Mina the HollowerMay 27, 2026
“Far from perfect, Mina the Hollower is still a particularly satisfying game, skillfully blending 2D Zelda, Souls-like elements, and original mechanics, all wrapped up in a Game Boy Color aesthetic that will melt the hearts of nostalgia-seekers. It does have a few collision issues and some odd game design choices, but nothing enough to detract from a solid experience from start to finish.”
read full review ↗ - 75Yoshi and the Mysterious BookMay 19, 2026
“Despite its strong concept, Yoshi and the Mysterious Book failed to fully win us over. Of the game’s dozens of short levels, only a handful stuck with us, due to significant repetitiveness in the gameplay and underdeveloped ideas. That said, we must commend the originality and risk-taking behind this new title from Good-Feel, which should delight trophy hunters and completionists.”
read full review ↗ - 85LEGO® Batman™: Legacy of the Dark KnightMay 18, 2026
“Ultimately, LEGO Batman: The Dark Knight’s Legacy is a must-have for anyone who loves LEGO games and the Batman universe. Its generosity and ingenuity in drawing on the best elements of the Arkham series elevate this installment to a higher level, making it far from “simplistic.” Its longevity is unquestionably among the best you’ll find in this genre, and the variety of gameplay options keeps things fresh enough to prevent boredom. Not to mention all the events involving Bruce Wayne and the Dark Knight that we relive, along with the usual shenanigans of the LEGO series, which give this new game a very unique flavor and identity.”
read full review ↗ - 85SAROSApr 23, 2026
“While more accessible than Returnal, Saros is still a real gameplay knockout. Its overly cryptic world will likely leave many players in the dust, and the replayability typical of roguelikes isn’t necessarily there, but it makes up for it with a string of memorable bosses and new ways to utilize Arjun’s abilities. As with Housemarque’s previous game, this is undoubtedly one of the best PS5 exclusives.”
read full review ↗ - 80Tomodachi Life: Living the DreamApr 15, 2026
“Aimed at players aged 7 to 77, Tomodachi Life: Living the Dream is a quirky game with an original concept and undeniable charm. More engaging than its 3DS predecessor, this unique life simulation combines absurd situations with a high degree of customization. And even if boredom starts to set in quickly, you always end up coming back to see how your Miis are doing.”
read full review ↗ - 65Crimson Desert EnhancedMar 18, 2026
“Crimson Desert’s best moments come when you think about the game it could have been, were it not for its overabundance of clunky mechanics and its painfully sluggish controls. Riddled with glitches and systems that don’t work, Pearl Abyss’s first single-player game can rely on its sublime open world, or its core management system borrowed from BDO, to occasionally lift us out of our frustration.”
read full review ↗ - 75Tales of Berseria RemasteredMar 2, 2026
“It's difficult to rate a remastered game like Tales of Berseria. The quality of the title released in 2017 is undeniable, and it ranks among the very best in the Tales of franchise, but we have to take into account what this new version actually brings to the table. It has to be said that, for $40, the graphical, technical, and content improvements leave something to be desired and do little to justify purchasing the game for those who already own the PS4 version. Nevertheless, the fact that this release on the current generation of consoles brings some improvements in terms of comfort and all the additional content released for the game may be a very good thing for players who have never had the chance to follow the story of Velvet Crowe. All in all, we recommend Tales of Remastered to JRPG fans who have never played the game before and to those who want to indulge in nostalgia; for everyone else, give it a miss.”
read full review ↗ - 75Pokemon PokopiaMar 2, 2026
“By taking the best ideas from Dragon Quest Builders and adapting them to Pokémon, Pokopia offers a proven formula that works well. With its extensive Pokédex and numerous secrets, Koei Tecmo's game delivers the essentials, but ultimately becomes tiresome. After an exciting initial discovery phase, the excitement eventually fizzles out, and what could have been a must-have for the Switch 2 ends up being just a decent experience for fans of pocket monsters.”
read full review ↗ - 80Mario Tennis FeverFeb 10, 2026
“It's beautiful, it's good, and it has perfectly decent content: ultimately, what more could you ask for? Perhaps less broken Fever Rackets, an Adventure mode worthy of the name, and ball physics with a little more bite. These are certainly notable flaws, but they don't detract from the undeniable effectiveness of this new Mario Tennis. Well done, Camelot !”
read full review ↗ - 80Nioh 3Feb 4, 2026
“Nioh 3 adds its own contribution to the series, with gameplay that is richer and more demanding than ever, and formidable bosses that require players to make good use of all the mechanics available to them. The more open and free structure of the world also allows players to explore and progress at their own pace, mitigating the difficulty. It's a shame that the level design tends to suffer as a result, while the clunkiness of previous titles tends to get worse, with an unsuitable interface and equipment management that is far too time-consuming in our opinion. This sequel should appeal to fans, but it may struggle to win over a new audience, especially with its increased price tag.”
read full review ↗ - 75Metroid Prime 4: BeyondDec 2, 2025
“After all these years of waiting, it's hard not to consider Metroid Prime 4 a bit of a disappointment. While the core gameplay is still as good as ever and there are still some flashes of brilliance in the level design, it's impossible to ignore the scars of what we can only guess was a tortuous development process. Sumptuous on Nintendo Switch 2, Retro Studios' latest title is perfectly acceptable, but it fails to make a lasting mark on the history of the famous franchise.”
read full review ↗ - 75Where Winds MeetNov 24, 2025
“Where Winds Meet is a surprising game in many ways, and if you manage to get through its unbearable first few hours, you may well find yourself drawn into its open world with its thousand promises. Completely free, once you get past the skin system, Everstone's title combines the combat of Sekiro with the exploration of Genshin Impact, incorporating MMO components that suit it perfectly. However, it's far from perfect: poor translation, the usual F2P retention mechanics, a lack of overall polish... The experience is good, certainly, but definitely not for everyone.”
read full review ↗ - 70Call of Duty®: Black Ops 7Nov 21, 2025
“Call of Duty: Black Ops 7 leaves a truly mixed impression. The campaign, which is too arcade-like and too similar to Zombie mode, lacks charm, pace, and consistency. Multiplayer offers solid content for a launch, but strays into excessive futurism that breaks the readability. Fortunately, Zombie mode clearly saves the day: complete, coherent, demanding, and fun, it recaptures the spirit of the best installments. Ultimately, this Call of Duty is solid in places, but very unbalanced when you look at it in detail. It feels like there was no balance in the development of each game mode. Some modes, notably Zombie, received more attention than others.”
read full review ↗